home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=90TT3447>
- <link 91TT0623>
- <link 91TT0281>
- <link 90TT2688>
- <link 89TT2270>
- <title>
- Dec. 24, 1990: The Leisure Empire
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990 Highlights
- The American Economy
- </history>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990
- Dec. 24, 1990 What Is Kuwait?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- BUSINESS, Page 56
- The Leisure Empire
- </hdr><body>
- <p>American entertainment has gone global and is changing both
- those who consume it and those who create it
- </p>
- <p>By CARL BERNSTEIN
- </p>
- <p> Just outside Tokyo 300,000 people troop through Japan's
- Disneyland each week, while 20 miles outside Paris a new city
- is rising on 8 sq. mi. of formerly vacant land. Once Euro
- Disney Resort opens for business in 1992, forget the Eiffel
- Tower, the Swiss Alps and the Sistine Chapel: it is expected
- to be the biggest tourist attraction in all of Europe. In
- Brazil as many as 70% of the songs played on the radio each
- night are in English. In Bombay's thriving theater district,
- Neil Simon's plays are among the most popular. Last spring a
- half-dozen American authors were on the Italian best-seller
- list. So far this year, American films (mostly action-adventure
- epics like Die Hard 2 and The Terminator) have captured some
- 70% of the European gate.
- </p>
- <p> America is saturating the world with its myths, its
- fantasies, its tunes and dreams. At a moment of deep self-doubt
- at home, American entertainment products -- movies, records,
- books, theme parks, sports, cartoons, television shows -- are
- projecting an imperial self-confidence across the globe.
- Entertainment is America's second biggest net export (behind
- aerospace), bringing in a trade surplus of more than $5 billion
- a year. American entertainment rang up some $300 billion in
- sales last year, of which an estimated 20% came from abroad.
- By the year 2000, half of the revenues from American movies and
- records will be earned in foreign countries.
- </p>
- <p> But the implications of the American entertainment conquest
- extend well beyond economics. As the age of the military
- superpowers ends, the U.S., with no planning or premeditation
- by its government, is emerging as the driving cultural force
- around the world, and will probably remain so through the next
- century. The Evil Empire has fallen. The Leisure Empire strikes
- back.
- </p>
- <p> "What we are observing," says Federal Reserve Board Chairman
- Alan Greenspan, "is the increasing leisure hours of people
- moving increasingly toward entertainment. What they are doing
- with their time is consuming entertainment -- American
- entertainment -- all over the industrialized world."
- </p>
- <p> For most of the postwar era, hard, tangible American
- products were the measure of U.S. economic success in the
- world. Today culture may be the country's most important
- product, the real source of both its economic power and its
- political influence in the world. "It's not about a number,
- though the number is unexpectedly huge," says Merrill Lynch's
- Harold Vogel, author of the 1990 book Entertainment Industry
- Economics. "It is about an economic state of mind that today is
- dominated by entertainment."
- </p>
- <p> What is the universal appeal of American entertainment?
- Scale, spectacle, technical excellence, for sure: Godfather
- Part III, Batman. The unexpected, a highly developed style of
- the outrageous, a gift for vulgarity that borders on the
- visionary: a Motley Crue concert, for example, with the drummer
- stripped down to his leather jockstrap, flailing away from a
- calliope riding across the rafters of the Meadowlands Arena in
- New Jersey. Driving plots, story lines and narrative: a Tom
- Clancy hero or one of Elmore Leonard's misfits. Indiana Jones'
- strength of character, self-reliance, a certain coarseness,
- a restless energy as American as Emerson and Whitman.
- </p>
- <p> "People love fairy tales," observes Czech-born director
- Milos Forman, "and there is no country that does them better
- than the United States -- whatever kind of fairy tales, not
- only princesses and happy endings. Every child dreams to be a
- prince; every adult has a secret closet dream to be Rambo and
- kill your enemy, regardless if it's your boss or communists or
- whoever."
- </p>
- <p> Donald Richie, the dean of arts critics in Japan, sees a
- broader appeal. "The image of America radiates unlimited
- freedom, democracy, a home of the people," says Richie. "This
- certainly appeals to the Japanese, who live in a very
- controlled, authoritarian society." Jack Valenti, president of
- the Motion Picture Association of America, concurs, arguing
- that American entertainment -- particularly movies, television
- and rock -- was a primary catalyst in the collapse of communism
- in Europe and the Soviet Union.
- </p>
- <p> On a recent visit to China, David Black, the supervising
- producer for Law & Order, watched young Chinese sell bootleg
- copies of Chuck Berry and Jerry Lee Lewis tapes in Shanghai.
- "In Hollywood," says Black, "we are selling them the ultimate
- luxury: the fact that people don't have to live the life
- they're born into. They can be a cowboy, a detective, Fred
- Astaire -- and that's what America is selling now. The hell
- with cars. Cars are just wheels and gears. People want to be
- able to play at being other people more than they want
- transportation."
- </p>
- <p> The process exacts a spiritual cost. At work sometimes in
- the iconography of American popular culture is a complex
- nostalgia for the lost American soul. Madonna is not Monroe,
- Stallone is not Billy Wilder. But they are cultural forces with
- an authority and resonance uniquely American. Such gilded
- presences radiate signals of material success and excess on a
- scale heretofore unknown in popular entertainment. Perhaps more
- important, their influence -- as models for imitation, objects
- of media attention -- far outweighs that of the traditional
- heroes and heroines in what may have been an earlier and more
- accomplished age. The very adulation that the global stars
- receive simultaneously diminishes and trivializes them, as if
- they were mere image and electricity.
- </p>
- <p> Money, lavish production, the big-budget blockbusters that
- only the American movie studios are willing to finance -- these
- are part of the appeal. And of course the newness of it all,
- whether in music or film or TV. Only in the U.S. does popular
- culture undergo almost seasonal rituals of renewal.
- </p>
- <p> Giovanni Agnelli, the Italian automobile industrialist, adds
- another factor: quality. "What is unique about American movies
- and popular music and television?" asks Agnelli. "They are
- better made; we cannot match their excellence."
- </p>
- <p> Nor, it seems, can anyone else on the world stage right now.
- Matsushita's purchase of MCA, like Sony's ownership of CBS
- Records and Columbia Pictures, signals a recognition of the
- value of integrating the yin and the yang of leisure economics,
- the hardware of VCRs and DAT and the software of music and
- programming. "Our entertainment is the one thing the Japanese
- can't make better or cheaper than us," says David Geffen, the
- largest single shareholder in the recent MCA-Matsushita deal.
- "That's why they are buying in. But they will have zero
- influence in the product. Companies don't decide what gets
- made; the content of American entertainment is inspirationally
- motivated."
- </p>
- <p> Michael Eisner, chairman of Walt Disney Co., and other
- industry executives argue that the unique character of American
- entertainment is the result of the polyglot nature of the
- society itself -- and the clash of cultures and races and
- traditions within it. The U.S. is the only country in the world
- with such a heterogeneous mix, uniquely able to invent rap
- music, Disney World, Las Vegas, rock 'n' roll, Hulk Hogan,
- Hollywood and Stephen King.
- </p>
- <p> A whole school of traditional economists is worried,
- however, that infatuation with the entertainment business and
- its glitzy success is symptomatic of a self-indulgent,
- spendthrift society deep into self-deceit. "The pre-eminence
- of entertainment is illusory success," warns Allen Lenz,
- economist for the Chemical Manufacturers Association. "It's no
- substitute for manufacturing. We need balance in our economy,
- not just the goods of instant gratification. The future of
- America is not in Michael Jackson records, $130 Reeboks and Die
- Hard 2. The fact is, you can't make it on Mickey Mouse."
- </p>
- <p> Or can you? Disney's Eisner is part of a powerful cadre of
- modern-day Hollywood moguls who have acquired what their
- predecessors only hoped to have: real global power -- economic,
- social, political. They exercise it through their stewardship
- of global entertainment conglomerates in the midst of a
- communications revolution that has changed the nature of the
- world. Eisner, Fox's Rupert Murdoch, Paramount's Martin Davis,
- Steve Ross of Time Warner (which owns the parent company of
- TIME), Ted Turner of Turner Communications, record executive
- Geffen, superagent Michael Ovitz and others have an astonishing
- influence on what the world sees, hears, reads and thinks
- about.
- </p>
- <p> "The most important megatrend of the century is the
- availability of free time," maintains Italian Foreign Minister
- Gianni De Michelis, who is working on a book about the new
- dynamics of global economy. "This is the reason the U.S. will
- remain the most important economy in the world -- because its
- GNP is increasingly geared to entertainment, communications,
- education and health care, all of which are about individuals
- `feeling well,' as opposed to the 19th century concept of
- services intended to protect the workplace and production."
- </p>
- <p> De Michelis' notion illustrates another aspect of today's
- entertainment business: the lines between entertainment,
- communications, education and information are increasingly
- blurred, and the modern U.S. entertainment company is uniquely
- positioned to provide software in all four areas.
- </p>
- <p> Just as the auto industry determines the basic health and
- output of a host of other industries (steel, plastics, rubber),
- the American entertainment business has become a driving force
- behind other key segments of the country's economy. As a result
- of this so-called multiplier effect, the products and profits
- of dozens of U.S. industries are umbilically tied to American
- entertainment: fast food, communications technology,
- sportswear, toys and games, sporting goods, advertising,
- travel, consumer electronics and so on. And the underlying
- strength of the American economy, many economists believe, has
- a lot to do with the tie-in of such businesses to the continued
- growth and world dominance of the American entertainment
- business and the popular culture that it exports.
- </p>
- <p> "The role of entertainment as a multiplier is probably as
- great as, or greater than, any other industry's," observes
- Charles Waite, chief of the U.S. Census Bureau of Economic
- Programs. "Unfortunately, there's no exact way to measure its
- effect." But if the American entertainment industry's
- boundaries were drawn broadly enough to include all or most of
- its related businesses, some economists believe, it could be
- credited with generating more than $500 billion a year in sales.
- </p>
- <p> Though the business is increasingly global, the domestic
- entertainment industry is still the backbone, and it is still
- thriving. The enormous profits of the '80s are being reduced
- by the recession. But the amount of time and money the average
- postadolescent American spends in the thrall of entertainment
- remains astounding: 40 hours and $30 a week, if industry
- statistics are to be believed. By the time U.S. culture goes
- overseas, it has been tried, tested and usually proved
- successful at home.
- </p>
- <p> Americans this year will spend some $35 billion on records,
- audio- and videotapes and CDs, almost as much as they will
- spend on Japanese hardware manufactured to play them. In the
- air-conditioned Nevada desert, the opening of two gargantuan
- amusement centers dedicated to gambling and show business --
- the Mirage and Excalibur hotels -- is leading Las Vegas toward
- its biggest year ever. In Nashville the country-music business
- is keeping the local economy afloat amid a tide of regional
- recession. Felix Rohatyn, the fiscal doctor, says the only hope
- for New York City, laid low by the collapse of the boom-boom
- Wall Street economy of the '80s, is to turn it into a tourist
- attraction keyed to entertainment. But the industry is also
- undergoing profound change in its essential financial and
- cultural dynamic: moving toward the European and Asian customer
- as a major source of revenue while moving away from American
- network television as the creative and economic magnet. Rambo
- III earned $55 million at home but $105 million abroad.
- </p>
- <p> Another effect of globalization: rather than waiting months
- or years before being released outside the country, American
- movies and television programs are beginning to enter the
- foreign marketplace in their infancy and even at birth -- and
- boosting profits. Universal opened Back to the Future II in the
- U.S., Europe and Japan simultaneously. The film made more than
- $300 million, and the receipts were available months earlier
- than usual, accruing millions of dollars in interest.
- </p>
- <p> The pervasive American presence is producing a spate of
- protectionist measures around the world, despite vigorous
- protests by American trade negotiators. The 12 members of the
- European Community recently adopted regulations requiring that
- a majority of all television programs broadcast in Europe be
- made there "whenever practicable."
- </p>
- <p> Leading the resistance to the American invasion has been
- France and its Culture Minister, Jack Lang, a longtime Yankee
- basher who has proclaimed, "Our destiny is not to become the
- vassals of an immense empire of profit." Spurred by Lang, who
- has gone so far as to appoint a rock-'n'-roll minister to
- encourage French rockers, non-French programming is limited to
- 40% of available air time on the state-run radio stations. But
- even Alain Finkelkraut, the highbrow French essayist and critic
- who is no friend of pop culture, concedes, "As painful as it
- may be for the French to bear, their rock stars just don't have
- the same appeal as the British or the Americans. Claude Francois
- can't compete with the Rolling Stones."
- </p>
- <p> In Africa, American films are watched in American-style
- drive-in theaters to the accompaniment of hamburgers and fries,
- washed down with Coca-Cola. One of the biggest cultural events
- in Kenya in recent weeks has been the national disco-dancing
- championships. But in Nairobi last month, two dozen
- representatives of cultural organizations held a seminar on
- "Cultural Industry for East and Central Africa" and concluded
- that something must be done to roll back Western (primarily
- American) dominance of cinema, television, music and dance. "Our
- governments must adopt conscious policies to stop the dazzle
- of Western culture from creeping up on us," Tafataona Mahoso,
- director of the National Arts Council of Zimbabwe, told the
- gathering.
- </p>
- <p> In Japan too, where the influence of American entertainment
- is pervasive, the misgivings are growing. "Younger people are
- forgetting their native culture in favor of adopting American
- culture," says Hisao Kanaseki, professor of American literature
- at Tokyo's Komazawa University. "They're not going to see No
- theater or Kabuki theater. They're only interested in American
- civilization. Young people here have stopped reading their own
- literature."
- </p>
- <p> Though movie admissions cost about $12 in Japan, customers
- seem willing to pay that to stand in the aisles for American
- films. "To the Japanese, American movies are hip and trendy,
- and Japanese audiences would rather die than be unfashionable,"
- says William Ireton, managing director of Warner Bros. Japan.
- </p>
- <p> Aside from the Islamic world, where laws based on
- fundamentalist strictures often forbid access to any
- entertainment, there seem to be very few places where that is
- not the case. Even in secular Iraq, teenagers jam the half a
- dozen or so little shops in downtown Baghdad that sell pirated
- copies of American rock-'n'-roll tapes and where the walls are
- covered with posters of Madonna and Metallica.
- </p>
- <p> The exponential growth of the American entertainment
- industry since the late 1970s has taken place in an era of
- extraordinary affection and goodwill toward the U.S. in the
- industrialized world. In Europe, Asia and even Latin America,
- anti-Americanism is lower than at any time since the Vietnam
- War. The phenomenon is in part self-fulfilling: to a large
- extent that goodwill can be traced to the projection of America
- as seen through its popular culture rather than to the nation's
- actual political or social character. If anything, there is
- an increasing dissonance between what America really is and
- what it projects itself to be through its movies and music.
- </p>
- <p> "Even in Nicaragua, when we were beating their asses in the
- most horrible way, they had this residual love for us,"
- observes author William Styron, who visited the country during
- the contra war. "They love us for our culture, our books, our
- heroes, our baseball players, our sports figures, our comic
- strips, our movies, everything. They had this consummate hatred
- of Reagan, but underneath was enormous love and affection for
- us as a kind of Arcadia."
- </p>
- <p> The American entertainment business captures much that is
- appealing, exuberant -- and excessive -- about the American
- character. The fantasies and limitless imaginations of
- Americans are a big part of who they are. It is also,
- ironically, the source of America's moral authority. For it is
- in the country's popular culture -- movies, music, thrillers,
- cartoons, Cosby -- that the popular arts perpetuate the
- mythology of an America that to a large extent no longer
- exists: idealistic, rebellious, efficient, egalitarian. In the
- boom time of their popular culture, Americans have found new
- ways to merchandise their mythologies. This is what America
- manufactures in the twilight of the Reagan era.
- </p>
- <p> Christopher Lasch, the social historian who wrote The
- Culture of Narcissism, sees the development of an
- entertainment-oriented economy as the final triumph of style
- over substance in the U.S. Lasch believes the most singular
- American psychological characteristic -- the desire for drama,
- escape and fantasy -- has come to dominate not only American
- culture and politics but even its commerce. "It's all of a
- piece. Its effect is the enormous trivialization of cultural
- goods. Everything becomes entertainment: news, political
- commentary, cultural analysis," he says. "The most significant
- thing about the process is that it abolishes all cultural
- distinctions, good and bad, high and low. It all becomes the
- same, and therefore all equally evanescent and ultimately
- meaningless."
- </p>
- <p> Is the imperialism of American popcult smothering other
- cultures, destroying artistic variety and authenticity around
- the world to make way for the gaudy American mass synthetic?
- "It's a horrible experience to go to the most beautiful place
- in the world only to turn on Crossfire," says Leon Wieselthier,
- the literary editor of the New Republic.
- </p>
- <p> "I've always felt that the export of our vulgarity is the
- hallmark of our greatness," says Styron, who lived for many
- years in Paris and whose books always sell well in France. "I
- don't necessarily mean to be derogatory. The Europeans have
- always been fascinated by wanting to know what's going on with
- this big, ogreish subcontinent across the Atlantic, this
- potentially dangerous, constantly mysterious country called the
- U.S. of A." American popular culture fills a vacuum, vulgar or
- not. "French television is a wasteland; ours is a madhouse. But
- at least it's vital," says Styron. "Dallas and Knots Landing
- and the American game shows are filling a need in France."
- </p>
- <p> Susan Sontag, whose 1964 essay Notes on "Camp" broke new
- ground in interpreting American popular culture, expresses
- doubt that the vitality of European culture will be
- extinguished by America's onslaught. "The cultural
- infrastructure is still there," she says, noting that great
- bookstores continue to proliferate in Europe. Rather than
- regarding Americans as cultural imperialists, she observes
- wryly, "many Europeans have an almost colonialist attitude
- toward us. We provide them with wonderful distractions, the
- feeling of diversion. Perhaps Europeans will eventually view
- us as a wonderfully advanced Third World country with a lot of
- rhythm -- a kind of pleasure country, so cheap with the dollar
- down and all that singing and dancing and TV."
- </p>
- <p> How long will the American cultural hegemony last? "I think
- we are living in a quasi-Hellenistic period," says Chilean
- philosopher Claudio Veliz, a visiting professor of cultural
- history at Boston University, who is writing a book on the
- subject.
- </p>
- <p> "In 413 B.C., Athens ceased to be a world power, and yet for
- the next 300 years, Greek culture, the culture of Athens,
- became the culture of the world." Much as the Greek language
- was the lingua franca of the world, Veliz sees the American
- version of English in the same role. "The reason Greek culture
- was so popular is very simple: the people liked it. People
- liked to dress like the Greeks, to build their buildings like
- the Greeks. They liked to practice sports like the Greeks; they
- liked to live like the Greeks. Yet there were no Greek armies
- forcing them to do it. They simply wanted to be like the
- Greeks."
- </p>
- <p> If America's epoch is to last, the underlying character of
- American culture must remain true to itself as it is pulled
- toward a common global denominator by its entertainment engine.
- But danger signals are already present: too few movies
- characterized by nuance, or even good old American nuttiness;
- more and more disco-dance epics, sickly sweet romances and
- shoot-'em-up, cut-'em-up, blow-'em-up Schwarzenegger
- characters; rock 'n' roll that never gets beyond heavy breathing
- and head banging; blockbuster books that read like T-shirts.
- The combination of the foreign marketplace and a young domestic
- audience nourished on TV sitcoms, soaps and MTV may be deadly.
- </p>
- <p> The strength of American pop culture has always been in its
- originality and genuineness: Jimmy Stewart and Bruce
- Springsteen, West Side Story and The Graduate, Raymond Chandler
- and Ray Charles, the Beach Boys and Howdy Doody, James Dean and
- Janis Joplin. It would be a terrible irony if what America does
- best -- celebrate its own imagination -- becomes debased and
- homogenized by consumers merely hungry for anything labeled
- MADE IN THE U.S.A.
- </p>
- <p> Another American century seems assured, though far different
- from the one now rusting out in the heartland. The question is,
- Will it be the real thing?
- </p>
- <p>_______________________________________________________________
- AT CENTER STAGE
- </p>
- <p> The U.S. now gets top billing worldwide in these markets:
- </p>
- <p>-- 75% of TV revenues
- -- 85% of pay-TV revenues
- -- 55% of movie revenues
- -- 55% of home-video revenues
- -- 50% of recording revenues
- -- 35% of book-sales markets
- </p>
-
- </body></article>
- </text>
-
-